Fundamental Analysis · Intermediate · 4 min
Reading guidance
You can read a company's guidance, compare it with the consensus and with earlier guidance, and explain the rules and limits behind it.
One sentence, big move
A quarterly report can contain fifty pages of numbers. On reporting day, a single sentence often moves the share more than all of them: what management expects for the rest of the year.
The numbers describe the past. The outlook describes the future, and the future is what the share price is built on. Reading guidance carefully, with its rules and its limits, is one of the most practical skills in fundamental analysis.
Old, consensus, new
Earnings guidance is a company's own forecast for a coming period, often given as a range: "sales of 3.9 to 4.0 billion for the year" or "earnings per share of 2.10 to 2.30". Some companies guide every quarter, some once a year, some not at all.
Read guidance in three ways:
- Against the old guidance. Raised, kept or cut?
- Against the consensus. Is the new range above or below what analysts expected?
- Over time. Does management usually meet or beat its own ranges?
A fictional company cuts its sales outlook:
The old guidance was 4.20 billion, and analysts expected 4.15. The new range of 3.90 to 4.00 billion is below both, even at its top end.
Two US rules shape guidance. Regulation FD, in force since 2000, requires companies to share material information with all investors at the same time, not first with selected analysts. And the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 created a safe harbor for a forward-looking statement that is identified as such and comes with meaningful cautionary language. That is why guidance always arrives with paragraphs of risks and caveats.
A forecast, not a promise
Markets usually read the direction of a change:
Raised guidance is often read as a sign that business is going better than planned. A cut is often read as the opposite, and it frequently moves the share more than the quarter's results.
But guidance is only a forecast, and it has incentives behind it. Some management teams guide cautiously, so that they can beat their own range later. Others are habitually optimistic. A company that met or beat its range in most of the last few years earns more credibility than one that had to cut repeatedly.
Not everyone thinks guidance is useful. In 2018, Warren Buffett and JPMorgan's Jamie Dimon argued publicly that quarterly earnings guidance encourages short-term thinking and called on companies to consider dropping it.
Common mistakes
- Treating guidance as a promise. It is a forecast, protected by cautionary language precisely because it may be wrong.
- Reading only the midpoint. Where the range sits against the consensus matters, and a wide range signals uncertainty.
- Ignoring the track record. Compare earlier guidance with what actually happened.
- Forgetting expectations. Unchanged guidance can disappoint if investors hoped for an increase.
The takeaway
Guidance is management's own forecast. Compare it with the consensus and the last guidance, and read it as a forecast, never as a promise.
Check yourself
Quick quiz
4 questions. Instant feedback, nothing is saved.
-
1Tap the figure that shows what analysts expected before the new guidance.
Tap the chart.
The consensus of 4.15 billion was the benchmark. Even the top of the new range, 4.00 billion, is below it.
-
2What does US Regulation FD require when a company shares its outlook?
Regulation FD, in force since 2000, forbids selective disclosure of material non-public information.
-
3Why do guidance statements come with long cautionary language?
The 1995 Private Securities Litigation Reform Act protects forecasts that are identified as such and come with meaningful cautions.
-
4A company repeats its guidance unchanged. How can that still move the share?
Like results, guidance is read against expectations.
of 4 correct.